Rankings / Best custom checkouts for Shopify
Best PayWhirl alternatives in 2026
PayWhirl is a solid option, and for some stores it's still the right one. If it doesn't fit yours on price, fees or payment providers, these are the checkouts worth a look, starting with ours. Each card shows what it costs, where it runs and its trade-offs.
Updated for 2026 · prices checked October 2026
Quick comparison
- 1Settl$34.99/monthShopify stores that want their own branded checkout on their own payment provider, with 0% per orderShopify
- 2PayWhirlFree plan · from $9/month + 2% per orderMerchants that bill subscriptions on Shopify and other sitesShopify, BigCommerce, and more
- 3Seal SubscriptionsFree plan · from $5,95/monthSmall stores that want cheap subscriptions with 0% feesShopify
- 4Appstle SubscriptionsFree plan · from $10/monthStores that want low-cost subscriptions with 24/7 supportShopify
- 5Rechargefrom $25/monthEstablished subscription brands that want the market leaderShopify
- 6Loop SubscriptionsFree plan · from $99/month + 1% per orderShopify subscription brands that want bundles and cancel flowsShopify
- 7CrispCheckout$99/month + 0.5% per orderShopify stores on Whop that want subscriptionsShopify
How we ranked
Settl is our product, so it's first. PayWhirl is second because it remains a strong choice for some stores; we say which ones. The rest are ordered by how close they are to what PayWhirl does.
Competitor details come from their public pricing pages and app listings, checked October 2026. Prices and plans change, so check each tool's own site before you decide. All names are trademarks of their owners; Settl isn't affiliated with them.
1. Settl
Our pick · Our productBest for: Shopify stores that want their own branded checkout on their own payment provider, with 0% per order
- Starting price
- $34.99/month
- first month $5.99 · 0% per order
- Platforms
- Shopify
Your own checkout on your own domain, paid through your own Whop, Stripe, Mollie, PayPal, Revolut, Airwallex or other account. Every paid checkout becomes a normal Shopify order.
Why stores pick Settl over PayWhirl
- 0% per order instead of a percentage on every renewal
- Your own branded checkout for one-off and subscription orders
- Renewals on your Stripe or Mollie account become Shopify orders
Cons
- – No subscription billing
- – No Shop Pay: buyers pay on your own checkout, not Shopify's
2. PayWhirl
Best for: Merchants that bill subscriptions on Shopify and other sites
- Starting price
- Free plan · from $9/month + 2% per order
- Platforms
- Shopify, BigCommerce, and more
Subscription billing for Shopify, BigCommerce or any website, with a monthly fee plus a percentage per transaction.
What PayWhirl does well
- Works off Shopify too
- Free plan with 0% on the first $5.000 processed
- US phone support and help with installation
Stay with PayWhirl if…
- You bill subscriptions on BigCommerce or a non-Shopify site.
- You want phone support and installation done for you.
Cons
- A percentage on every plan: 3% on Free, 2% on Pro ($9/month)
- On Shopify it uses Shopify's checkout and gateways
3. Seal Subscriptions
Best for: Small stores that want cheap subscriptions with 0% fees
- Starting price
- Free plan · from $5,95/month
- Platforms
- Shopify
Budget Shopify subscription app for memberships, boxes, free trials and digital access, with 0% transaction fee on every plan.
Pros
- Free plan, paid from $5,95/month
- 0% transaction fee on all plans
- 4.9 stars from over 3.100 reviews on the Shopify App Store
Cons
- Price rises with your number of subscribers
- Subscriptions only; Shopify's checkout and payments stay as they are
4. Appstle Subscriptions
Best for: Stores that want low-cost subscriptions with 24/7 support
- Starting price
- Free plan · from $10/month
- Platforms
- Shopify
Shopify subscription and subscription-box app with 0% transaction fee and the most reviews in the category.
Pros
- Free up to $500/month in subscription revenue, then from $10/month
- 0% transaction fee
- 5.0 stars from almost 9.000 reviews on the Shopify App Store
Cons
- Price tiers rise with subscription revenue
- Subscriptions only; it doesn't change your checkout or provider
5. Recharge
Best for: Established subscription brands that want the market leader
- Starting price
- from $25/month
- Platforms
- Shopify
The largest Shopify subscription platform, running on Shopify's checkout. It now also owns Skio.
Pros
- Mature churn prevention and failed-payment recovery
- Entry plan at $25/month with no transaction fees for the first 50 subscribers
- 4.8 stars from over 3.100 reviews on the Shopify App Store
Cons
- Starter is $99/month plus 1.49% + 19¢ per transaction
- Subscriptions stay on Shopify's checkout and payment setup
6. Loop Subscriptions
Best for: Shopify subscription brands that want bundles and cancel flows
- Starting price
- Free plan · from $99/month + 1% per order
- Platforms
- Shopify
Shopify-native subscription app with bundles, cancel flows, dunning, a branded portal and one-click checkout links.
Pros
- Free plan up to 50 active subscriptions
- Bundles, cancel flows and upgrade offers in the portal
- 5.0 stars from 781 reviews on the Shopify App Store
Cons
- Starter is $99/month plus 1.0%
- Stays on Shopify's checkout and payment setup
7. CrispCheckout
Best for: Shopify stores on Whop that want subscriptions
- Starting price
- $99/month + 0.5% per order
- Platforms
- Shopify
Branded Shopify checkout powered by your own Whop account, on your own domain, with orders created in Shopify.
Pros
- Self-serve setup; free to build and preview before going live
- Subscriptions with dunning and a customer portal (Pro)
- Drag-and-drop builder with raw HTML, and one-click refunds to card and Shopify
Cons
- Whop is the only payment provider
- 0.5% per order on top of $99/month per store
Questions
What is the best PayWhirl alternative in 2026?+
For most Shopify stores that want their own branded checkout on their own payment providers, we think Settl: $34.99 a month and 0% per order. Settl is our product, so weigh that. The other checkouts on this page are good picks for specific needs.
Why is PayWhirl ranked second?+
Because for some stores it's still the best fit. We list what PayWhirl does well and who should stay with it, so you can decide for yourself.
How do I switch from PayWhirl to Settl?+
Connect your own payment provider accounts, style your checkout and add one line to your Shopify theme. Every paid checkout becomes a normal Shopify order, so stock and fulfilment keep working as they do now.
Where do the prices on this page come from?+
From each tool's public pricing page, checked October 2026. Prices change, so check their own site before you decide.
How much does Settl cost?+
The checkout is $34.99 a month (first month $5.99), or $54.99 a month with 99,9% Tracking included. 0% per order from Settl; your payment provider's own fees apply.